Air Accidents Investigation Branch home

Report No: 1/2005. Report on the accident to Sikorsky S-76A+, G-BJVX near the Leman 49/26 Foxtrot platform in the North Sea on 16 July 2002

Date of occurrence: 16 July 2002

Summary:
 
Lowestoft Coastguard notified the accident to the Air Accidents Investigation Branch (AAIB) at 2000 hrs on 16 July 2002 and the investigation began that same day. The following Inspectors participated in the investigation:

Mr J Barnett - Investigator-in-Charge
Mr N Dann - Operations
Mr K Conradi - Operations
Mr R Parkinson - Engineering
Mr S Moss - Engineering
Mr R Vance - Flight Data Recorders
Mr A Foot - Flight Data Recorders

The aircraft operator's base at Norwich operates S-76 helicopters in support of offshore oil and gas operations in the southern North Sea. On the evening of the accident the aircraft departed Norwich to complete a scheduled flight consisting of six sectors in the southern North Sea offshore gas fields. The first four sectors were completed without incident but whilst en-route between the Clipper, an offshore production platform, and the Global Santa Fe Monarch, a drilling rig, the aircraft suffered a catastrophic structural failure. The helicopter's main rotor assembly separated almost immediately and the fuselage fell to the surface about 0.8 nm north-west of the Global Santa Fe Monarch which at the time was attached to the Leman 49/26 Foxtrot platform, a normally unmanned installation. Witnesses reported hearing a single or double muffled bang or boom, and seeing the aircraft fall into the sea. The fuselage disintegrated on impact and the majority of the structure sank. Fast rescue craft launched from the Putford Achilles, a multipurpose standby vessel, arrived at the scene of the accident within a few minutes. There were no survivors amongst the nine passengers and two crew.

The investigation identified the following causal factors:

i) A manufacturing anomaly created an area of reduced insulation between a main rotor blade's spar and one section of its two-piece leading edge erosion cover.

ii) The affected blade had been struck by lightning.

iii) Electrical energy from the lightning strike exploited the manufacturing anomaly and caused microstructural damage that was not detectable when the blade was returned to its manufacturer for assessment.

iv) The blade was repaired before being returned to service and a fatigue crack in the spar originated from the microstructural damage.

v) An opaque protective patch applied to the erosion cover's scarf joint hid exterior symptoms of the developing spar crack that appeared before the accident.

vi) The helicopter's proprietary onboard Health and Usage Monitoring System (IHUMS) did not provide sufficient warning of impending blade failure in time to avert the accident.

vii) There were no in-flight symptoms of impending blade failure that the pilots should have recognised.

Six safety recommendations have been made.

Click here to read full details of this incident

Report name:
AAR 1/2005 - Sikorsky S-76A+, G-BJVX
Registration:
G-BJVX
Type:
Sikorsky S-76A+
Location:
Near the Leman 49/26 Foxtrot platform in the North Sea
Date of occurrence:
16 July 2002
Category:
Commercial Air Transport - Rotorcraft
Summary:
 
Lowestoft Coastguard notified the accident to the Air Accidents Investigation Branch (AAIB) at 2000 hrs on 16 July 2002 and the investigation began that same day. The following Inspectors participated in the investigation:

Mr J Barnett - Investigator-in-Charge
Mr N Dann - Operations
Mr K Conradi - Operations
Mr R Parkinson - Engineering
Mr S Moss - Engineering
Mr R Vance - Flight Data Recorders
Mr A Foot - Flight Data Recorders

The aircraft operator's base at Norwich operates S-76 helicopters in support of offshore oil and gas operations in the southern North Sea. On the evening of the accident the aircraft departed Norwich to complete a scheduled flight consisting of six sectors in the southern North Sea offshore gas fields. The first four sectors were completed without incident but whilst en-route between the Clipper, an offshore production platform, and the Global Santa Fe Monarch, a drilling rig, the aircraft suffered a catastrophic structural failure. The helicopter's main rotor assembly separated almost immediately and the fuselage fell to the surface about 0.8 nm north-west of the Global Santa Fe Monarch which at the time was attached to the Leman 49/26 Foxtrot platform, a normally unmanned installation. Witnesses reported hearing a single or double muffled bang or boom, and seeing the aircraft fall into the sea. The fuselage disintegrated on impact and the majority of the structure sank. Fast rescue craft launched from the Putford Achilles, a multipurpose standby vessel, arrived at the scene of the accident within a few minutes. There were no survivors amongst the nine passengers and two crew.

The investigation identified the following causal factors:

i) A manufacturing anomaly created an area of reduced insulation between a main rotor blade's spar and one section of its two-piece leading edge erosion cover.

ii) The affected blade had been struck by lightning.

iii) Electrical energy from the lightning strike exploited the manufacturing anomaly and caused microstructural damage that was not detectable when the blade was returned to its manufacturer for assessment.

iv) The blade was repaired before being returned to service and a fatigue crack in the spar originated from the microstructural damage.

v) An opaque protective patch applied to the erosion cover's scarf joint hid exterior symptoms of the developing spar crack that appeared before the accident.

vi) The helicopter's proprietary onboard Health and Usage Monitoring System (IHUMS) did not provide sufficient warning of impending blade failure in time to avert the accident.

vii) There were no in-flight symptoms of impending blade failure that the pilots should have recognised.

Six safety recommendations have been made.

Download report:
PDF icon G-BJVX Pub version.pdf (1,663.71 kb)